When it comes to distinguishing between headphones vs headsets, it’s important to note that while people often use these terms interchangeably, they can actually be surprisingly different pieces of equipment. At a basic level, headphones are designed as a small pair of head-mounted speakers that are meant to be worn over the user’s ears. They provide a private audio experience suitable for enjoying music, podcasts, or any other form of auditory media.
On the other hand, headsets share the same design and function as headphones, but they come with an additional feature that sets them apart – a built-in microphone. This extra feature makes headsets useful for activities that require communication, such as gaming, video calls, voice chats, and more. The microphone allows users to audibly interact with others while still enjoying sound through the head-mounted speaker portion of the device.
Considering the overlap in their baseline function, it’s easy to assume that in a comparison of headphones vs headsets, headsets would always be the better option, thanks to the added versatility of having a built-in microphone. However, it’s important to remember that every decision comes with a cost. Opting for extra features isn’t necessarily always the ideal choice, especially if what you truly need is excellence in a specific aspect. So, when making a selection between headphones and headsets, it’s best to determine your exact requirements and prioritize what matters most to you.
By delving deeper into the features, strong points, and drawbacks of both classes of devices, hopefully, you’ll be able to form your own informed opinion on which truly is the best-suited audio companion for your needs. So then, let’s see what these devices can do and what might be best for you.
Headphones: How do they work?
The reproduction of audio through speakers is a common aspect shared by both types of devices—headphones, and headsets. Therefore, the following information is applicable to both. At the core of any speaker lies the diaphragm, which vibrates in response to a signal-bearing current.
The diaphragm is usually composed of a thin sheet of plastic or metal, carefully engineered to be both lightweight and rigid. It is connected to a metal frame, which provides support and stability. The diaphragm, along with its frame, is positioned within a cup lined with foam or other cushioning material.
The aforementioned diaphragm is connected to a set of magnets. When current passes through the magnets, it creates a fluctuating magnetic field that is the true cause of the diaphragm’s vibration. These vibrations correlate to the signal carried by the current. The resulting vibration of the diaphragm is then what creates sound waves that are transmitted to the user’s ears. Ultimately all sound is just the vibration of particles in a medium that our ears can detect
These speaker components of a set of headphones or headset are also known as drivers. They function as transducers, converting electrical signals into audible sound waves, and are thus the most critical component of a pair of headphones. The sound quality of the headphones is primarily determined by the quality of the drivers. Amplifiers are also important components. They serve to boost the strength of the electrical signal that gets fed into the drivers, which results in the generation of louder volumes of sound.
Generally, when it comes to audio devices, headphones tend to offer greater sound quality in comparison to headsets at a similar price point. The reason behind this lies in the fact that headphones are designed to be single-purpose dedicated devices, allowing for the full value of a given set’s worth to be invested in. This enables manufacturers to focus on incorporating the highest quality drivers, amplifiers, and other relevant attributes, all of which synergistically work together to enhance the user’s overall listening experience and produce exceptional sound quality.
Moreover, one noteworthy advantage of dedicated headphones, especially when considering the price per pound, is the exceptional comfort they provide to the wearer. Since there is no need to allocate the cost towards the inclusion of other electrical components required for a decent microphone, manufacturers can direct the remaining production budget towards the use of high-end, lighter, and otherwise more ergonomic materials. This not only enhances the aesthetic appeal but also contributes to a more comfortable and enjoyable listening experience.
By investing in quality headphones, users can generally be more assured in knowing that the cost they pay primarily goes towards creating a more immersive and satisfying audio journey.
Headsets: What sets them apart?
As mentioned earlier, both headphones and headsets have a common feature: their speaker elements. However, beyond their capability to reproduce sound, headsets offer additional functionality. This includes a built-in microphone, which enables users to record audio. In a sense, the microphone can be considered the inverse counterpart of a speaker. It captures and converts ambient sound waves into electrical signals, adding versatility to the headset’s capabilities.
There are multiple kinds of microphone designs available, including dynamic, condenser, and electret mics. Notably, electret microphones are widely favored in headsets for their remarkable reliability and outstanding performance. With the simple yet powerful addition of this feature, a headset transforms into a versatile communication device, offering seamless two-way communication capabilities. This convenient integration of speakers and microphones in headsets not only opens up a world of possibilities but also ensures effective and efficient audio communication in various scenarios, from professional settings to casual conversations and beyond.
In contrast to how a pair of headphones specializes in providing their user with an inherently personalized individual hearing experience, a headset can do the same while also potentially being used as a tool for social connection and interaction at potentially vast differences. This flexibility allows users to seamlessly transition between private audio enjoyment and engaging in virtual conversations with others.
With a headset, users can immerse themselves in soundscapes of usually quite serviceable quality while also being able to connect with friends and colleagues in virtual environments, enhancing their social experiences and creating new opportunities for collaboration and communication. Whether it’s tuning out the world or tuning in to connect, a headset offers the versatility to cater to an individual’s needs in both personal and social contexts.
When comparing a pair of headset speakers to those in an equivalently priced pair of headphones, the former may generally fall short in terms of audio capability and quality. The headset speakers, although capable of delivering satisfactory audio, might not match the immersive and refined sound experience offered by headphones. Additionally, dedicated microphones are likely to offer better recording performance in terms of clarity and capturing nuances.
However, what makes a combination of recording and audio reproduction capabilities in a single device truly remarkable is the synergy it creates. This synergy opens up exciting possibilities for new audio experiences that transcend the limits of traditional setups. With this unique combination, users can not only enjoy high-quality audio reproduction but also effortlessly record their voices for the purpose of communication during both work and play, all with a single, multifunctional device.
Headphones vs Headset Takeaway
As with most things in life, there’s rarely a singular right answer. When it comes to the dilemma of choosing between headphones and headsets, the decision ultimately boils down to your specific purposes and use cases as a user. Each class of device has its unique uses and benefits that cater to different needs.
Headphones excel in providing dedicated personal audio experiences, immersing you in a world of rich and high-quality sound. They are perfect companions for music enthusiasts, audiophiles, or anyone who simply enjoys losing themselves in rhythm and melodies.
On the other hand, headsets offer all-in-one solutions to your communication needs. They not only deliver crisp and clear audio but also feature built-in microphones, allowing seamless voice communication in various settings. Whether you’re gaming, making calls, or participating in virtual meetings, headsets provide convenience and functionality for effective communication.
By understanding the breakdown of functions and individual benefits between headphones vs headset, you’ll be better equipped to determine which option is currently most suited to your specific needs. So take into account your audio preferences, communication requirements, and comfort preferences to make an informed decision that enhances your overall experience.
In addition to being the Founder and Editor-in Chief at HearingPeople.com, Luis Zuluaga is the founder and CEO of Florida Hearing Institute, an innovative hearing health enterprise in South Florida, focused on bringing high-tech hearing devices at affordable prices to people with hearing loss. Before his latest hearing healthcare endeavors, Luis served as President and Chief Operating Officer of Zounds Hearing Inc., a US-based hearing aid manufacturer that introduced many technical innovations to the hearing aid market.